Your #1 choice for auto repair & service
Fleming Island, Orange Park, Middleburg
and Surrounding Areas
Why Choose Us
Dealer Alternative for Affordable, Quality Repair Services

- FAMILY-OWNED & OPERATED
Serving Clay county and surrounding areas since 2014.
- ASE-CERTIFIED
ASE-certified technicians with Master Techs on staff with years of experience and training.
- Reliable and Trustworthy
Quality, professional service you can trust.
- Digital Inspections
Transparency and Convenient Inspections at your fingertips.
- SERVICING DOMESTIC & ASIAN VEHICLES
All domestic & Asian makes and models including fleets.*
- WARRANTY
24 months/24,000 miles.
- CONVENIENT DROP-OFF AND LOANERS
Free LOCAL shuttle service within 6 miles. We also have loaner cars available by reservation.
*Please note we do not service European or diesel vehicles

Who We Are
Fixing them right.
Making them last.
OUR MISSION…. is to genuinely care about people and their vehicles while providing a first-class auto-repair experience with honesty and integrity.
“We love getting to know you! It is our goal to build relationships in our community and understand your concerns. At Legacy, we take pride in our attention to detail and our commitment to your satisfaction.”
When Mark and Vanessa founded Legacy Automotive in 2014, they knew immediately what the motto of their new business should be:
“Fixing them right. Making them last.”
That’s because an automobile is the second biggest expense for most families after their house, and Mark and Vanessa believed that their neighbors in Middleburg deserved a repair shop they could trust to protect their investment.
For more than a decade, Legacy Automotive has worked hard to build a reputation as THE place you can trust for ALL of your automotive repair and maintenance needs, no matter how big or small.
That’s why we service ALL makes and models with ASE Certified technicians, and back all of our repairs (including parts AND labor) with 24 months/24,000 miles. It’s also why we named ourselves Legacy Automotive: we want our repair shop to be our legacy as we seek to raise the bar in the auto service industry.
AUTOMOTIVE REPAIR & MAINTENANCE
Our Services
A/C Repairs
When temperatures rise, a reliable car air conditioning repair service ensures a cool and comfortable ride. We service 134A and R1234YF A/C systems.
Brakes
Prompt brake repair ensures safe journeys, providing peace of mind with every stop.
Maintenance
Routine automotive maintenance, including timely oil changes, ensures optimal engine performance and longevity for your vehicle.
Diagnostics
Car diagnostics pinpoint underlying issues, enabling efficient and effective repairs to keep your vehicle running smoothly.
Alignments
Car alignments fine-tune wheel angles to optimize handling, stability, and tire longevity.
FIND US
OUR LOCATION
2487 County Rd 220
Middleburg, FL 32068
( UNIT 102 – Behind Clay County Transmission)
Hours: Mon – Fri 8:30 AM – 5:00 PM
REVIEWS
What Our Customers Say
EXCELLENT Based on 452 reviews Susan Ebey2025-07-09Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Quick service, very friendly and helpful So glad we trusted them with air conditioner car repairs. Price was better than others some others in Clay County,Florida. Will go there again. Ray Davis2025-06-20Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. First off, I’m super hard to impress. I’m always worried about companies doing me wrong. I had lots of bad past issues with companies. Most companies these days require you to stay on top of things. Not legacy automotive. They helped me with my Mustang and gave me free advice on the electrical issue in the past. They even gave me a cheaper towing company and saved 30 bucks from the other company I used. Right then, I knew whoever owned this business was about doing quality work and ensuring their name was good and customers were cared for. Weeks later, I took my Honda Accord to them to fix the VTEC rattle. These guys didn’t cut corners; they did everything I needed. I had a spreadsheet of all the items I needed done without even having to worry if they would cut corners. Tom showed me pictures of everything they would do, and he was super chill with my ocd. He stayed on the phone with me for 45 minutes, reviewing everything with all my questions and my ocd type personality. I had many bad companies do me wrong, so I was initially skeptical. But Tom wasn’t like that at all. He is a wonder guy. Communication was spot on. I can’t ask for a better company. The owner, Mark, ever personally reached out to ensure I was good and thanked me for my business. Call me old school here, but this doesn’t exist often. These guys are my go-to from now on. Also, the lady at the front desk is so kind and warm to customers. The mechanics are top-notch here. I would give them 10 stars if I could. It's the best place around for a personality like mine. Thank you. Cari B2025-06-17Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. This was a fantastic experience. I took my car in for maintenance services. I made a drop off appointment, but, they do offer appoinments for those times when you need to wait for your car. They were friendly, patient and helpful. The text notifications and a link to the detailed complimentary inspection report with suggested additional services made verifying and accepting the quote/cost convenient and simple. The cost was reasonable and within my expectations. I will be back. Zach2025-05-13Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Fixed the A/C in my F-250 in a very timely manner and the customer service was great. Highly recommend this shop!! Mike Mariani2025-03-30Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Helped me with my broken window on my f150. Got me in right away, fixed the window and changed the oil. 1 day in and out, Great Service and price! Thank You Legacy.. Mike M Kitty Lane2025-03-28Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Legacy Automotives is thorough, efficient, and accurate. Love the mechanics and Kaely who runs the front office - but I think she's a mechanic, too.
WARRANTY
WE ACCEPT MOST EXTENDED WARRANTIES AND PERFORM FACTORY MAINTENANCE.
Some believe that they need to have their car serviced at the dealership to maintain their factory warranty, but Federal Law actually prohibits new car dealers from denying warranty service because routine scheduled maintenance was performed at an independent repair facility. We at Legacy Automotive can provide you with factory recommended maintenance and repairs with honest work at affordable prices that will not affect your factory warranty. We can also repair and file any claims for extended warranties purchased for your vehicle. So give us a call today at Legacy Automotive!
BLOG
Car Care Tips

Maintenance and Auto Repairs: What Every Driver Should Know
Owning a car isn’t just about the freedom of the open road; it also involves the responsibility of maintenance and repairs. As vehicles become more complex, paying attention to a vehicle’s status should be a part of every driver’s journey. Understanding the basics of car maintenance can save you time, money, and stress down the … Read more

Keeping Your Car Moving With Tire Shops
When it comes to vehicle maintenance, tires are often overlooked until an issue arises. However, keeping your tires in optimal condition is essential to ensuring your safety and maintaining your car’s performance. Tire shops play a crucial role in helping you achieve this goal, offering expert services and advice. They are your go-to resource for … Read more

Why DIY Car Repairs Can Cost You More in the Long Run
With an abundance of how-to videos and DIY car repair guides online, it’s easy to assume you can handle fixes yourself and save a few bucks. But while it might seem like a smart short-term solution, doing your car repairs can lead to bigger, more expensive problems in the long run. It’s tempting to think … Read more